Faultory

Dossier · 12 case files · 1628–2023

Structural failures: bridges, buildings and hulls.

Bridges that twisted, walkways that fell, hulls that cracked and a skyscraper repaired at night: how structures fail and what the evidence shows.

Backdrop: The Vasa seen from the side in the Vasa Museum, Stockholm. Jules Verne Times Two · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons. Figure: Gustav II Adolf (Gustavus Adolphus). King of Sweden who was at war with Poland-Lithuania and pressed for the Vasa to be sent to sea (17th century). Paulus Pontius · Public domain · Wikimedia Commons.

A structure fails when a load finds a path its designers did not check: wind from an unexpected angle, a connection detail changed during construction, steel that turns brittle in the cold, or a crack that grows a little with every cycle until the remaining metal cannot hold.

These investigations follow inquiry reports, engineering papers and the surviving physical evidence. They show how calculations, materials, construction changes and inspection regimes combine, and why some of the most instructive cases are the ones where someone noticed the problem in time.

In date order of the event. Each file is a full investigation: briefing, source-linked evidence, reasoning steps and findings.

CH 35History & technology

The ship that heeled too far

Vasa (ship)

Vasa, 1628: a warship that capsized in Stockholm harbour on her maiden voyage

9 min3 reasoning stepsIntermediateBegin investigation

CH 38History & technology

The dam that could not spill

Johnstown Flood

Johnstown Flood, 1889: why the South Fork Dam failed, and what the record can say about responsibility

10 min3 reasoning stepsIntermediateBegin investigation

CH 25Engineering & technology

A dead load nobody rechecked

Quebec Bridge collapse

Quebec Bridge, 1907: how an estimated weight became a structural failure

10 min3 reasoning stepsIntermediateBegin investigation

CH 78History & technology

Three suspects for a burst tank

Great Boston Molasses Flood (1919)

Boston, 1919: why did a storage tank burst and send a deadly wave through the North End?

12 min4 reasoning stepsIntermediateBegin investigation

CH 01Engineering & technology

The bridge that fed its own motion

Tacoma Narrows Bridge

Tacoma Narrows, 1940: follow the energy, not just the wind

9 min3 reasoning stepsIntermediateBegin investigation

CH 26Engineering & technology

Hulls that broke in still water

Liberty ships and T2 tanker fractures

Schenectady and the Liberty fleet, 1943: why welded hulls split

9 min3 reasoning stepsIntermediateBegin investigation

CH 27Engineering & technology

Loads repeated, cracks unseen

de Havilland Comet losses, 1954

de Havilland Comet losses, 1954: pressurized-cabin fatigue and the tank tests

10 min3 reasoning stepsIntermediateBegin investigation

CH 28Engineering & technology

One eyebar, no second path

Silver Bridge collapse

Silver Bridge, 1967: how did a flaw in one eyebar bring down the span?

10 min3 reasoning stepsIntermediateBegin investigation

CH 69Engineering & technology

The wind that came from the corner

Citicorp Center wind-bracing crisis (1978)

Citicorp Center, New York, 1978: how did the engineer find that the tower could fall in a storm, and what made the risk worse?

14 min4 reasoning stepsAdvancedBegin investigation

CH 05Engineering & technology

The detail that carried two walkways

Hyatt Regency walkway collapse

Kansas City, 1981: trace where the weight goes

9 min3 reasoning stepsIntermediateBegin investigation

CH 34Engineering & technology

Footsteps that tuned a bridge

London Millennium Bridge sway

London Millennium Bridge, 2000: why a crowd made a footbridge sway

8 min3 reasoning stepsBeginnerBegin investigation

CH 66Engineering & technology

Readings from a hull under strain

Titan submersible implosion (2023)

Titan submersible, 2023: what did the hull’s own monitoring data show before the final dive?

14 min3 reasoning stepsAdvancedBegin investigation

From the journal

The ideas behind these cases.

Other topicsSoftware failures 15Aviation and spaceflight 16Energy and power grids 7Medicine and public health 11Mysteries and open questions 7Extraordinary claims and replication 9Markets, money and fraud 6Weather, climate and the Earth 11Ships and the sea 9Investigations from the 2020s 12Astronomy and physics 13